T. Rev (st_rev) wrote,
T. Rev
st_rev

On Metaphysics

Existence isn't a monic or absolute property. I mean, does Mickey Mouse exist?

As a sentient being, mostly no. (Someone method-acting/role-playing Mickey Mouse kind of counts as a version of Mickey Mouse as a sentient being, in a very narrow sense.)

As a recognizable image, mostly yes. (The three-overlapping-circle motif will inspire a consistent experience of recognition in anyone who's been exposed to enough Disney products, but that's really a large class of images with very fuzzy boundaries.)

As a unitary individual, physically instantiated in the material body of an anthropomorphic mouse? Absolutely not.

As a copyrighted name governed by a certain body of laws and defended by a team of lawyers? Absolutely yes.


Platonism is stupid.
Subscribe

  • T. Rev and Random's Guide to Lovecraftian Drinking

    rfrancis informs me that this essential document from ancient days is in the process of falling off the edge of the Internet. For…

  • Rev's Law

    This seems like it ought to be a well-known principle, but I can't find it set down anywhere, so I am claiming it for myself. Rev's Law: Given…

  • Goodbye Tumblr

    Made a Tumblr account about a week ago. Using Tumblr was like eating a cake and slowly realizing it had been made with spoiled eggs. Just deleted…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 35 comments

  • T. Rev and Random's Guide to Lovecraftian Drinking

    rfrancis informs me that this essential document from ancient days is in the process of falling off the edge of the Internet. For…

  • Rev's Law

    This seems like it ought to be a well-known principle, but I can't find it set down anywhere, so I am claiming it for myself. Rev's Law: Given…

  • Goodbye Tumblr

    Made a Tumblr account about a week ago. Using Tumblr was like eating a cake and slowly realizing it had been made with spoiled eggs. Just deleted…